Saying Goodbye: Intentionally ending a friendship

Saying goodbye or ending a relationship is never easy. In this post I explore the topic of friendship and also how I intentionally ended a friendship of 8 years with a male friend.

Saying Goodbye

The Six Principles to Mature Masculinity

One principle every two days. The framework behind everything on this site.

Ending a relationship is never easy. After the first flush of a new relationship or friendship things can go downhill and without commitment and intention so many friendships end up in a fuzzy no-mans land, where we just drift away from each other. We still like each other but perhaps too much has been left unsaid. 

Friends versus lovers

There are some similarities and differences when it comes to friends versus lovers. The big difference is the physical intimacy that we enjoy with our partners binds us much closer than to our friends. This creates a hierarchy where your partner, children and perhaps extended family are more important than our friendships. 

Of course, there’s always that new relationship energy when you’re getting to know someone new, whether this is just as a friend or more physically intimate. It’s the fun part of any relationship.

But ultimately friendships tend to fall into a second-class category compared to partner, kids and family. We all know and accept this on some level. This is the small print of the friendship contract. But friendships clearly also need to be nurtured and maintained. 

The dying art of friendship

I don’t know if it’s just me but being a friend and having friends seems to be a dying art. Most people are so busy, with kids, work, hobbies and their partners and family, that it’s difficult to invest any time in regularly maintaining relationships with those outside that inner circle. 

As someone who has moved country twice in my adult life, with a scattered family in South Africa, England and Italy, I’ve had to work hard to actively seek out friendships with other men. Men in particular are hard to reach because of the demands of family life. But men are often brought together by common interests or hobbies. In my case it’s Brazilian Jiu-jitsu, climbing, camping and hiking, yoga, running and meditation.

Breaking up with a friend

My buddy and I live in different countries and met up IRL every couple of years in a different European city. We first met in Vienna at a popular annual tech conference. We had interests like tech, martial arts and vegetarianism in common. We struck up a mainly online friendship catching up on Skype every 6 weeks or so. We did this consistently for 8 years. 

This year we attended the same European tech conference and got to spend time together in real life after a break of 5 years. This is when it became really apparent that we no longer had that much in common and that our friendship had been stuck for a while. Having an online relationship is very different from actually spending time in the same physical space with someone. Our time together highlighted this for me. 

As the week went on I had this growing feeling that I needed to end the relationship so that I could move on. My buddy could tell that something was up but at first I couldn’t quite put my finger on why I was so abrupt and stiff with him. But whenever I was around him I found my energy draining and I felt tired and irritated. After a few days of this I went to him and said “We need to talk”. 

It’s not an easy thing to end any relationship. I’ve done my share of dumping girlfriends, been dumped and had a couple of divorces too, but I’ve never sat down with a male friend and said. “I’d like to end our friendship”. I don’t think there’s ever a good time to do this. It just rose up and erupted from my mouth. He stared at me blankly and then after a pause said “Are you breaking up with me?” The only answer I had was “Yes”.

Our words ebbed away like a rapidly receding low tide, and there seemed nothing left to say. I told him that I was in town for a few more days and that I could make time if he wanted to discuss any more or process. He declined and we parted ways. 

Reflections

It’s been a few months since I ended the friendship and one reflection I’ve had is that part of my feeling trapped in the friendship was my friend’s unwillingness to make changes for the better in his life. He’s been unhappy in his marriage for years and we’ve had countless discussions about it. Eventually, we stopped talking about it. But he was still clearly very unhappy. He just lacked the courage to improve on his situation. 

At the end of the day it’s not my place to judge whether he needs to get a divorce or get marriage counseling. But something needed to change. I’ve come to realize that I’m intolerant of those who don’t step into the fire of the difficult decisions that ultimately shape and mold us as better men. The reason why I’m intolerant of it, is because it’s important to me to do, and I need to surround myself with men that model this behaviour. Men who are doing what needs to be done, in an intentional way. 

But I also miss my friend and part of me wonders what other gifts we could have given each other. 

I’m unlikely to know whether ending our friendship turned out to be a positive or negative experience for him. For myself I know that I feel lighter and it’s created the space for me to focus on more rewarding relationships with new men.

Guy Anderson

Being dumped

I realize as I’m writing this, that another friend of mine actually modelled the intentional ending of our friendship for me. It was just before I left England. We’d been friends for about 10 years and I’d made the decision to leave the UK. We arranged to hang out and he told me he was saying goodbye and that he was not going to stay in touch. 

He wanted to let me go and move on. It was a beautiful and vulnerable moment. I could see it was important for him to let me go and I feel grateful that he’d thought enough about our relationship and what was important for him to bring it to a conclusion in such a thoughtful and loving way. Did it sting? Yes it sure did.

Father time

None of us have an infinite amount of time. Everyone including ourselves is changing as we age. We’re either changing intentionally or we’re being forced to change by life and often it’s both. We have daily responsibilities… family, kids, work, eating, sleeping, working out… If our friendships are low commitment and low reward then how many of them can we have? Also, do long-term friendships that have flatlined, still serve us? Do we still feel like we’re friends with our old school buddies? Do these old friendships still occupy emotional storage space?

Duty and loyalty

Perhaps the friendships we have with distant school friends don’t actually matter anymore. But maybe we still feel a sense of duty and loyalty to our old friends. Perhaps we’re holding onto a part of our lives that has gone and if we let go of the relationships from that time, we would feel like we’re betraying a part of ourselves. 

One thing I do know is that life and relationships have different seasons and some people are with us for a short time, perhaps too short, while others seem to overstay their welcome.

Showing appreciation

We don’t always have control over when someone leaves our life, but perhaps we can be a bit more intentional about who we would like to keep and make sure that they know that we love them and appreciate them. This way we can turn our energy towards those relationships we value and feel rewarded by. 

The beginning and the end

Beginnings are often easy while endings can be really hard. Sometimes it’s difficult to feel that the ending we’re going through is actually the beginning of something else. One very clear example of this is my second divorce. It was exactly what I needed to get me to make the changes I needed and to finally step into mature masculinity. But it was also one of the toughest periods of my life over a period of several years.

Conclusion

This has not been a comfortable blog post to write and it’s been sitting half-finished for far to long. But it’s clear to me how important it is to me to have rewarding relationships with those I love.

I’ve never intentionally ended a friendship before and the process has certainly made me think more deeply about the role that friendships with other men play in my life.

I also feel grateful that I have a band of brothers in my life that I could call today and check in with. You know who you are!