Of Boys and Men Book Review: Why Boys Are Struggling and What We Can Do About It
A compassionate review of Of Boys and Men, exploring why boys are falling behind—and how fathers and mentors can support healthier masculinity and growth

The Six Principles to Mature Masculinity
“The problem with men today is not that there is too much masculinity, but too little of the right kind.”

What happens when boys grow up without clear guidance, purpose, or role models?
If you've been paying attention — to rising dropout rates, mental health struggles, fatherlessness, and the disconnect so many men feel today — you already know something's wrong. After watching Adolescence on Netflix and reflecting on my own journey, it became clear to me: boys are being left behind.
Richard Reeves’ Of Boys and Men is the book we didn’t know we needed. It’s not angry. It’s not self-pitying. It’s clear, compassionate, and unflinching in its diagnosis of a quiet cultural crisis: boys are struggling, and nobody’s talking about it.
The Core Problem: Boys Are Falling Behind
Reeves lays out the data with surgical clarity. Across the West, boys are:
- Performing worse than girls in school
- More likely to drop out of university
- More prone to addiction and suicide
- Struggling to find direction, work, and emotional stability
This isn’t about demonizing progress for women. It’s about recognizing a parallel decline that’s gone largely ignored. Reeves argues that while we’ve made needed strides in lifting up girls, we’ve failed to ask: What happens to boys in the absence of meaningful male roles, rites of passage, and emotional guidance?
Some shocking statistics from Of Boys and Men
⅓
Boys represent just one third in the top 10% academically. Girls represent two-thirds.
26%
Men earn 26% fewer bachelor’s degrees than women.
50%
Boys are 50% more likely to fail basic literacy and numeracy tests at age 15 than girls.
250%
Men die by suicide at a rate 250% higher than women.
80%
Men account for nearly 80% of opioid overdose deaths in the U.S.
25%
1 in 4 children in the U.S. lives without a father in the home
These numbers aren’t just statistics — they represent real lives, and real suffering. And behind each one is a story of a boy who didn’t get what he needed to thrive.
“Helping boys and men doesn’t mean turning back the clock. It means building a better future for everyone.”

Masculinity Isn’t the Problem — Disconnection Is
One of the book’s most important contributions is this: it refuses the lazy narrative that masculinity itself is the problem. Instead, it draws attention to disconnection — from fathers, mentors, meaningful education, and a healthy sense of what it means to become a man.
There’s a beautiful parallel here to our last book review, Can’t Hurt Me by David Goggins. Goggins finds strength through sheer willpower. Reeves zooms out and shows us what happens when structures and support systems fail boys altogether. Both are necessary voices in a broader conversation.
What We Can Do: Rethinking Support for Boys
Reeves doesn’t just diagnose the problem. He offers grounded, actionable solutions:
- Introduce more male teachers and mentors
- Rethink education models that leave boys behind
- Value vocational training alongside academic paths
- Create new narratives of healthy masculinity
This isn’t about going backward. It’s about meeting boys where they are and building systems that nurture emotional growth, resilience, and purpose.
At Modern Savage, we believe men need spaces to grow, to connect, and to reflect. Reeves’ work affirms this mission on a societal level. If we want emotionally healthy, grounded men, we need to start with the boys they once were.
My Reflections on Of Boys and Men
My own life reads like the stats from the book. I scraped through high school. I got myself into all kinds of trouble and lacked any healthy, mature, and strong role models to help guide and shape my life as a young man.
It was only after the crisis of my first divorce at 27 that I changed my life around. Over the last two and a half decades, I've painstakingly rebuilt my life and forged my character.
But it's not been an easy journey. I went through a second life-changing divorce after becoming a father. Of Boys and Men reminds me not only of my own struggles to find my place in society but also the challenges my own son will have to navigate.
Of Boys and Men is a powerful reminder that we have a lot of work to do as a society, while my own experience reveals that personal transformation can have a direct, rippling, positive effect on those around us.
We don't have to wait for society to change in order to grow as individuals.
Take a moment
What messages did you receive about being a man when you were younger? What do you wish had been different?
Journal exercise
Write a letter to your teenage self. What would you tell him about masculinity, strength, and belonging?
Are you a father to a son?
How can you support your son to grow into a healthy, happy and productive young man: a man who can meet the challenges of tomorrow’s world, lead and thrive?
Final Thoughts: The Cost of Silence
We can’t afford to keep quiet about the crisis facing boys and men. Not just because of what it means for individuals, but because of what it means for families, communities, and future generations.
Of Boys and Men doesn’t offer a quick fix. But it offers something more powerful: clarity, compassion, and hope. It invites us — as men, fathers, brothers, sons — to take responsibility for shaping a better path.
